Decision tool30 projects

Compare Home Repair Costs Side by Side

Pick any two roofing, HVAC or plumbing projects to see their typical ranges on one scale, with labor hours, permits and what each range covers.

Common comparisons:

AC Unit Replacement averages $6,200 more than AC Compressor Replacement.

Difference in national average

+$6,200

AC Unit Replacement averages $6,200 more (400%) than AC Compressor Replacement.

AAC Compressor Replacement$800 – $2,800
BAC Unit Replacement$5,500 – $10,000
Typical range National average High endSame scale for both projects.
AC Compressor Replacement compared with AC Unit Replacement
MeasureA · AC Compressor ReplacementB · AC Unit Replacement
Typical range$800 – $2,800$5,500 – $10,000
National average$1,550$7,750
Low end to high end$600 – $3,000$3,750 – $14,000
Estimate confidenceHighMedium
Planning estimate of on-site hoursNot a published figure2 – 4 h4 – 8 h
Contractor billing rateAs stated in the guide's labor section$60 – $150/hr$75 – $250/hr
Labor share of the typical billShare the ZIP adjustment scalesAbout 35%About 32%
PermitNot usually priced$50 – $1,500
TradeHVAC Mechanics and InstallersHVAC Mechanics and Installers
What the range covers
Show what it coversReplacing an AC compressor typically costs $800 to $2,800 for parts and installation, about $1,550 on average: Fixr publishes that range and average, This Old House reports the same $1,550 average, and Angi reports $800 to $2,300 ($1,200 average). Larger systems can pass $3,000 (Fixr). Under a manufacturer parts warranty you still pay about $600 to $1,200 for labor and refrigerant (Fixr). An existing R-410A system can still be repaired with R-410A. If the system is over 10 years old or the repair is more than $1,000, This Old House suggests pricing a whole new AC unit as well.
Show what it coversReplacing a central AC unit typically costs $5,500 to $10,000 for a 3-ton system on existing ducts (Fixr), which covers the outdoor unit, a matched indoor coil and installation. Other publishers report: This Old House $8,460 on average ($6,345 to $10,575), Angi $5,978 ($3,887 to $8,073) and Fixr's 2026 installation page $6,000 ($5,000 to $12,000). Size moves the price most: Fixr lists $4,250 to $7,500 installed for 2 tons and $7,800 to $14,000 for 5 tons, and new ductwork adds $3,600 to $9,500. New systems now use R-454B or R-32 refrigerant. If only the compressor failed, a repair at $800 to $2,800 may be enough on a younger system.
GuidesRead the AC compressor replacement guideRead the AC unit replacement guide

National figures from each guide's cited sources. Labor hours and billing rates come from each guide's labor section, which says which are published; the labor share is the one the guide's ZIP adjustment scales. Not contractor quotes.

How to read it

Reading a cost comparison

  1. 01

    Compare like with like

    A repair and a replacement solve different problems. Check what each range covers (the last rows of the table) before reading the difference as a saving.

  2. 02

    Read the high end

    The brass marker is the upper end shown in each guide. Hidden damage, access and code upgrades push a job toward it.

  3. 03

    Labor figures

    Crew hours, billing rates and labor shares come from each guide’s labor section, and the guide says which of them are published and which are modeled.

  4. 04

    Repair or replace

    Most guides include a repair-versus-replace section with the rules their sources publish, such as equipment age and the cost of the repair relative to a replacement.

To price your own project, open the guide and use its calculator, or start from the calculators page.